Donald Trump’s promise to launch mass deportations, starting with Haitian immigrants in Springfield, Ohio, has triggered widespread outrage and drawn comparisons to some of history’s darkest moments. Speaking at his golf course in California, Trump vowed that if re-elected, he would begin the largest deportation effort in U.S. history, focusing on communities like Springfield and Aurora, Colorado. His statements have been criticized as dangerous, fear-mongering, and even “Hitlerian.”
“We will do large deportations from Springfield, Ohio, large deportations,” Trump told reporters. “We’re going to get these people out. We’re bringing them back to Venezuela,” he continued, despite the fact that most immigrants in Springfield are from Haiti and are in the U.S. legally under programs like Temporary Protected Status (TPS) and humanitarian parole.
Trump’s rhetoric has drawn comparisons to authoritarian leaders, with many noting its incendiary nature. USA Today columnist Rex Huppke condemned the former president’s statements, writing on social media, “This is Hitlerian rhetoric… He’s dehumanizing legal immigrants, and for some reason saying he’ll deport Haitians to Venezuela.” Huppke, who has followed Trump closely for years, added that Trump had “devolved to his most base, hateful level.”
The Haitian community in Springfield, which consists of approximately 12,000 to 15,000 people, has been the target of escalating hate speech and threats. Over the past few weeks, schools and government buildings in the town have received bomb threats, which many attribute to the inflammatory remarks made by Trump and his running mate, Senator JD Vance. The pair have falsely claimed that newly arrived Haitian immigrants are stealing and eating pets in the city. These unfounded accusations have spread widely on far-right social media platforms, sparking fear and hostility toward the Haitian community.
The majority of Haitian immigrants in Springfield are there legally, working under TPS or the Biden administration’s humanitarian parole program, which allows immigrants from countries experiencing armed conflict or humanitarian crises to stay in the U.S. legally. Despite their legal status, they have been demonized by Trump’s campaign, which has repeatedly targeted immigrants to rally his base.
Temporary Protected Status grants legal protections and work permits to immigrants from countries experiencing war or natural disasters. However, it does not offer permanent legal status. Thousands of Haitians in Springfield are here under this program, which means they are authorized to live and work in the U.S., filling critical labor shortages in a town that has struggled economically for decades. Many Haitians moved to Springfield after the town experienced a heavy decline in manufacturing during the 1990s, and they have become an essential part of the workforce.
Despite the contributions of Haitian immigrants, Trump’s rhetoric has escalated, falsely claiming that they are responsible for a range of social problems in Springfield, including disease, crime, and rising rent prices. These accusations have been amplified by Sen. JD Vance, who posted on social media: “In Springfield, Ohio, there has been a massive rise in communicable diseases, rent prices, car insurance rates, and crime.” Vance added, “This is what happens when you drop 20,000 people into a small community.”
These claims have been repeatedly debunked by local officials. Springfield’s mayor, police chief, and Ohio Governor Mike DeWine, a Republican, have all stated that there is no evidence to support the allegations that migrants are involved in crime or that pets are being stolen or eaten. DeWine has also pledged state support to help Springfield manage the influx of immigrants, dedicating $2.5 million to expand primary care access for local residents, noting that many Haitian immigrants had limited or no access to health care in their home country.
National immigrant rights advocates have spoken out against Trump’s rhetoric, warning that his inflammatory language not only dehumanizes immigrants but also incites violence. Vanessa Cárdenas, executive director of America’s Voice, described Trump’s words as part of a broader pattern of fear-mongering and conspiracy theories that actively court political violence. “The lies and conspiracies about Haitians are part of a larger volume of anti-immigrant and dehumanizing rhetoric that actively courts political violence,” Cárdenas said in a statement. She also compared Trump’s rhetoric to “antisemitic blood libel,” referencing historical hate speech that has led to violence against marginalized groups.
Cárdenas emphasized the dangers of such rhetoric for immigrant communities, noting how violence has already manifested in attacks on Jewish, Latino, and Black Americans in recent years. “In addition to the lies about Haitians, which echo tropes like the antisemitic blood libel, Trump described this nation in increasingly violent and graphic terms… What’s the potential response from an unhinged supporter hearing those words and believing those threats? It is violence like the Haitian community is fearful of, and Jewish, Latino, and Black Americans have already experienced in places like Pittsburgh, El Paso, and Buffalo,” she warned.
Trump has doubled down on his threats of mass deportations, promising that these efforts will be “bloody” if necessary. “We’re going to have the largest deportation in the history of our country,” he told reporters, further inflaming tensions. This promise has drawn further condemnation from immigrant rights advocates and progressives across the country, who view these threats as part of a larger authoritarian agenda aimed at dividing the nation.
In Colorado, Gladis Ibarra, co-executive director of the Colorado Immigrant Rights Coalition, also spoke out against Trump’s rhetoric. “Trump’s fear-mongering is as dangerous as it is dishonest,” Ibarra said. “He doesn’t care about Aurora or Colorado. He’s using us as political pawns to push a racist agenda that paints our entire community in a bad light, and we won’t fall for it. Immigrants are our teachers, our neighbors, our parents, and our children. We will not let them be demonized or ripped from our communities.”
As Trump continues to escalate his anti-immigrant rhetoric, many are warning of the potential consequences. The Biden administration, meanwhile, has spoken out against these inflammatory statements. During a recent event at the White House honoring Black excellence, President Biden condemned Trump’s remarks about Haitian immigrants. “This has to stop, what he’s doing. It has to stop,” Biden said.
Despite the divisive language, advocates like Vanessa Cárdenas urge Americans to reject this dark vision for the country. “The majority of Americans who reject this dark and dystopic vision and the lies courting violence should come together to denounce this outrageous spectacle of hatred and to chart a different direction for our nation,” Cárdenas said.
COMMENTS