A recent investigation by Haaretz has shed light on the deeply troubling practice of the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) using Gaza civilians, including children and the elderly, as human shields and booby trap detectors. This report, based on testimonies from IDF soldiers, highlights a pattern of abuse that raises serious questions about Israel’s adherence to international humanitarian law.
The use of human shields by the IDF is not a new allegation. Accusations of such practices date back to the founding of Israel in 1948 and have been a recurring issue in the country’s numerous conflicts with Palestinian territories. Legally, the use of human shields is prohibited under international law, specifically under Protocol I of the Geneva Conventions, which classifies such actions as war crimes. Despite this, evidence suggests that the IDF has repeatedly violated these standards.
In 2002, during the Second Intifada, the Israeli High Court of Justice issued a temporary injunction banning the use of human shields by the IDF. This ruling was in response to reports that soldiers were forcing Palestinian civilians to act as buffers during military operations. However, this injunction did not put an end to the practice. In 2010, two IDF staff sergeants were convicted of using a 9-year-old Palestinian boy as a human shield during Operation Cast Lead in 2008-09, forcing him to open bags suspected of containing explosives. These soldiers received only suspended sentences and demotions, avoiding prison time. Numerous subsequent instances of IDF soldiers using human shields have gone unpunished.
The Haaretz investigation adds to this troubling history, revealing that the use of civilians as booby trap detectors is a widespread practice in the ongoing conflict in Gaza. Soldiers interviewed by Haaretz described how Palestinian civilians, including minors, are captured and forced to walk ahead of Israeli troops during raids to ensure that the areas are not rigged with explosives. One soldier admitted, “When I saw the report from Al Jazeera, I said, ‘Ah, yes, it’s true.’” He added that this practice is done with the full knowledge of IDF commanders, stating, “It’s done with the knowledge of the brigade commander, at the least.”
These revelations follow earlier reports from Al Jazeera, which documented instances of Palestinians being strapped to the hoods of Israeli combat vehicles and sent into buildings and tunnels to check for booby traps. These reports sparked international outrage and were initially met with denials from the IDF. However, the Haaretz investigation confirms that such practices are indeed taking place and are not isolated incidents but part of a broader pattern.
The soldiers’ testimonies paint a disturbing picture of the IDF’s operations in Gaza. One soldier described how “really old people were made to go into houses” to ensure they were safe for Israeli troops. Another recounted how Palestinian captives were told they would be set free if they completed one tunnel mission for the IDF. Some soldiers expressed discomfort with these practices, with one recalling, “People began to ask questions, very quickly a mess began about this procedure.” However, resistance within the ranks appears limited, with most soldiers either complicit or unwilling to challenge their commanders.
The IDF’s response to the Haaretz report has been to reiterate its official stance that the use of human shields is prohibited. The IDF Spokesperson’s Unit stated, “IDF instructions and orders prohibit the use of Gazan civilians caught in the field for military missions that pose a deliberate risk to their lives.” The statement added that the allegations would be forwarded to the relevant authorities for review. Despite these assurances, the history of such allegations and the lack of accountability in past cases cast doubt on whether meaningful action will be taken.
International human rights organizations and observers have long criticized the IDF for its treatment of Palestinian civilians. The Israeli human rights group B’Tselem has documented numerous cases where the IDF has ignored or violated the injunction against using human shields. The ongoing conflict in Gaza has only intensified these concerns, with the IDF’s actions raising serious questions about Israel’s commitment to upholding international law.
The use of human shields by the IDF not only violates the rights of Palestinian civilians but also exacerbates tensions in the already volatile region. These practices undermine any efforts toward peace and fuel resentment among Palestinians, who see them as further evidence of Israel’s disregard for their lives and dignity.
As the international community continues to grapple with the complexities of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, the revelations from the Haaretz investigation underscore the need for greater scrutiny of Israel’s military practices. The use of human shields is a gross violation of human rights and a clear breach of international law. It is imperative that the Israeli government and the IDF take these allegations seriously and hold those responsible accountable.
The findings of this investigation also highlight the broader issue of accountability within the IDF. As long as soldiers and commanders can engage in such practices with impunity, the cycle of violence and abuse will continue. For there to be any hope of progress, Israel must confront these violations head-on and take concrete steps to ensure that its military operates within the bounds of international law.
One soldier’s candid admission captures the troubling mindset within the IDF: “The thinking is that it’s better for the Israeli soldiers to remain alive and for the [Palestinians] to be the ones blown up by an explosive device.”
COMMENTS